!á½ p="justify">
With the Democrats taking control of Congress by overpowering the incumbent Republicans last Tuesday in the mid-term elections, the political landscape in Washington has changed. A new era is beginning in America. The reason for President Bush’s defeat is another analysis entirely. So how will the current picture affect Turkey?
Ankara has been trying to repair the relations with the Republican Bush administration that were seriously strained during the Iraq war. However, giving precedence to strengthening relations with the party in power didn’t allow for the establishment of necessary communications with the Democratic opposition. Until now, a big part of the work was handled with the help of the lobbying firm of former Republican leader Bob Livingston. But now the Congress is in the hands of the Democrats…
Should Turkey take on an air of “the old king is dead; long live the new king”? I think not, because although the Republicans have lost the majority, close to half the Congress and the White House are still in their hands. Consequently, even if they are weakened, they still have power that shouldn’t be underestimated. On the other hand, there is no reason why Ankara shouldn’t show the Democrats flexibility in advancing relations. Even if we’re a little late, we haven’t missed the train completely…
Most of the Democratic leaders who will hold key positions in Congress’ foreign policy have problems with Ankara for different reasons. Future Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, Senate Leader Harry Reid, Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee Joe Biden, and House International Relations Committee Chairman Tom Lantos can all be included in this category. It is important to dissipate the chilliness with key Democratic leaders. If Prime Minister Erdogan had been able to realize his Washington visit after January 2007, and had been able to meet with Democrats instead of coming during the election campaign period when Congress was on vacation, it would have been much more productive…
The Democrats’ general viewpoint on the issues of Iraq and the alleged Armenian genocide, which carry near-future crisis potential in Turkish-American relations, is rather far from Turkey’s. They may not be able to decisively implement everything they said before the elections. However, many influential Democrats have become dangerously engaged with the Armenian lobby regarding their genocide claims. When it comes down to the bottom line, President Bush will interfere again, but it’s questionable as to how effective the Republican White House’s request to the Democratic leaders in Congress will be. An important factor of most Democratic campaigns was Turkey’s not looking favorably on an immediate pull-out of troops from Iraq because of its anxiety about its leading to increased chaos. It is known that some like Senator Biden support possibilities that even include Iraq’s being divided into three different states.
If the Armenian resolution passes Congress in April, if steps are taken in Iraq to deepen Turkey’s concerns, and if concrete measures are not taken against the presence of the PKK, we might very well find ourselves in a new Turkish-American crisis in the spring. Just the Armenian genocide issue alone is enough to poison Turkish-American relations. Imagine how the already Washington-sensitive Turkish public opinion and ruling establishment would respond. Fears of the eastern part of the country being divided between the Armenians and Kurds would hit the roof. The perception that the U.S. is not Turkey’s friend would be strengthened. With Ankara entering an election atmosphere, it would not be easy to find a brave knight to stand up for Turkish-American relations. And the common strategic vision between the two countries could be seriously damaged.
Let’s look at the bright side. The tracks Democratic President Bill Clinton left behind in Turkish-American relations are an important legacy. The Democrats’ adopting a more internationalist and world-harmonious image than the Republicans is an advantage for Turkey. It is expected that the Baker-Hamilton Commission, which has turned into a vehicle for salvaging the situation for both parties, will recommend mechanisms that make Iraq’s neighbors a part of the solution. Consequently, our quotient of being listened to in Washington can increase. The Democrats will try and draw a more realistic and pragmatic foreign policy line than the idealistic, surrealistic and maximalist line represented by the neocons. They might want to put the breaks on democratization in the Middle East and partially return to former pro-stability policy and spread reforms out over a longer period of time. Most Democrats see diplomatic engagement with Syria and Iran as more suitable to American interests. They want to rejuvenate the peace process in the Middle East. All of these are compatible with Ankara’s line.
The change in the political picture in America can lead to tactical variation in its foreign policy, but its general strategic stance won’t change much. It is a strategic necessity that the United States not offend an important regional power like Turkey. Turkey can not be taken for granted as before. If Turkey becomes offended, it can not make a sufficient contribution to straightening out the grave position of the U.S. and Israel in the Middle East, and the hands of the radicals would be strengthened in the war against terror. Turkish-American strategic relations should not be sacrificed to internal political concerns in both countries. Train-wrecks could be avoided by intense dialogue.